Girl’s Night In: Cookie Exchange Party

comments icon 17 comments

Cookie Exchange Party Pack Printables

When I think Christmas, I think COOKIES!  And while friends and sweets are probably two of my favorite things, as the weather gets colder, my gal pals and I are less and less likely to venture out! NO PROBLEM! The Dating Divas bring you an exclusive cookie exchange party printable pack to host the ULTIMATE Cookie Exchange Party for a fun and memorable Girl’s Night IN! The greatest part is your holiday baking can include just one kind of cookie, but you get to enjoy all the great cookie recipes your friends bake, too!

With the hustle and bustle of the holidays, it can be hard to find time to actually organize and plan a beautiful cookie-swapping party.  BUT this printable party pack lays out easy step-by-step instructions, making planning your enviable cookie exchange care-free and FUN!  Your friends will think you spent months prepping for this gorgeous holiday get-together!

Cookie exchange printable pack with everything you need to host the perfect party! #TheDatingDivas #CookieExchange

This CHEERFUL cookie exchange party printable pack, designed exclusively for The Dating Divas by the talented Courtney at All Things Bright and Beautiful, not only allows you to fit in some quality BFF time but also take part in the spirit of the holidays.  PLUS, families will be pleased when you send home all your friends with super-cute boxes of holiday cookies to share!

Inside The Cookie Exchange Printable Party Pack At a Glance:

  1. Cookie Swap Party Planner
  2. Cookie Party Invites, Exchange Rules and Recipe Cards
  3. Hot Cocoa Bar Station Printables
  4. Instructions for an adorable Cookie Box
  5. Cookie Voting Sheets and Awards
  6. Cookie Trivia
  7. AND MORE!

So…. Here it is: the planning, prepping and hosting of the ULTIMATE Cookie Exchange!

Planning the Cookie Exchange Party

We’ve got you covered in creating a stress-free and fun cookie swap for your friends! Use the planning checklist and shopping list to map out exactly what materials you’ll need in addition to the gorgeous printables included in this pack! First on the checklist: Send out the party invites, including our cookie exchange rules and holiday cookie recipe cards.

Cookie Exchange Rules

As your RSVP’s start rolling in, you should also be receiving completed cookie recipe cards from your guests with their cookie of choice.  Be sure to make copies of each holiday recipe for each cookie swap guest!

Cookie Exchange Party Supplies

With a few craft supply items and ALL of the gorgeous printables found in your Cookie Exchange Party kit, you are now ready to prep for your party!  Start by creating your Cookie Exchange Banner!

Cookie Exchange Party Decorations

Hang some of the received holiday recipe cards from your banner as additional decor! Featured friends will feel EXTRA special! {wink wink}

Cookie Swap Party Banner

Also, now that you know what delicious holiday cookies will be coming to the party, you can start creating your label cards with each cookie name for the cookie display table!

Cookie Exchange Party Table Tents

Next, the AH-dorable cookie boxes!  Although they may look tricky, they are SIMPLE and a nice touch! *All the instructions to create the two versions of the paper plate boxes are found within your printable kit!

Cookie Exchange Party Favors

Cookie Exchange

Okay, ALMOST there on the prep work! WOW, is this cookie party going to be AMAZING or what?! NOW, what goes better with cookies and friends than hot cocoa?!  We’ve included everything you need to create the ultimate Hot Cocoa Bar, including straw tags, mug tags, table sign and napkin ring holders.  This table ALONE will get your holiday party started!

Ladies Cookie Exchange Party

How To Plan A Cookie Exchange Party

Voila! Prepping the Cookie Exchange: CHECK!

Hosting A Cookie Exchange

It’s party time! What makes a cookies swap host memorable?!  One that provides gorgeous decor and fun activities to go along with her party!  … Guess what?… You have both!  Now that your home is beautifully decorated, it’s time to line up the activities for the evening!

Cookie Exchange Party Ideas

First, make sure each party guest has their own copy of the tasting mat, voting sheet and cookie trivia answer sheet.

Cookie Exchange Games

Start the evening by having each of your party guests taste ALL the delicious cookies in attendance…while sipping on their cocoa, of course! After each cookie has been sampled, guests can vote for the AWARD-winning cookies (there are blank voting cards if you’d like to create your own cookie award categories).  We’ve included a handy “Cooking Tasting Card,” with different categories to help you rate each yummy dessert.

Cookie Exchange Party Games

Tally all the final votes and award the cookie chefs accordingly with these cute DIY awards!  Feel free to add your personal touches to the top cookie awards!

Cookie Swap Party

If you think you know a lot about cookies, think again! As the host, quiz your guests with a fun, 10-question quiz that might even stump the brightest cookie connoisseur in attendance! They can record their answers on their blank Cookie Trivia printable sheet!  May the “smartest cookie” win!

Christmas Cookie Trivia Questions

As the evening winds down, make sure your cookie party guests don’t leave empty-handed.  And although their hands (and tummies!) might be FULL of cookies, don’t forget to send them off with your festive party favor!

Cookie Exchange Party Favors

Hosting the ULTIMATE Cookie Exchange: CHECK! 

Our one-of-a-kind cookie exchange printable pack will help you create a memorable Girl’s Night In with your favorite people!

Yummy cookies + Best Friends + Lots of Laughter = Our Tried and True Recipe for Holiday FUN!

Get everything you need to host your own
Holiday Cookie Exchange Party

for just $8.97!

Add to Cart

Your tasty cookies will be a GREAT addition to all the fun activities listed in our DIY Christmas Countdown printable packs! 

Printable Christmas Countdown

Be sure to create yours before December rolls around to create a Holiday season like never before! We’ve included fun adventures just for your spouse AND ones for the WHOLE family!



I am madly in love with three men (1 big and 2 little)! I am lucky enough to be married to my true complement. I spend my days doing any and everything 'boy!' I have a passion for fitness and love trying anything that makes my heart race.

Learn more about Paige
Free 7-day Program

One week to a better marriage.

Sign up now and get our 7 Days of Love Program absolutely free!

Husbands or Wives
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

You Might Also Like

diamond iconWe love your comments

We LOVE hearing from our readers! Thanks for leaving us some love!

Recent Comments

    1. Jody, Oh no!! Please email our amazing Customer Service Diva – Ferren ( – and she will help get those right to you!! 🙂 XOXO

    1. Hi Charlotte! This is a digital kit, so you only need to buy it once! Then you can print as many copies of each item as you need! Hope that helps 🙂 xoxo

See More Comments